A few weeks ago I asked on my personal LinkedIn page a question “Would you consider IECEx Certificate of Personal Competency Training ?”, and of the 187 respondents, 43% were for a yes, and 34% wanted to know what the difference is. So, in this blog, I intend to reveal the ancient mysteries behind CompEx and IECEx.
Both schemes follow the same set of standards. IEC 60079 series, and in the main, IEC 60079 parts 14 (selection, erection, and initial inspection), and part 17 (maintenance and inspection). Nothing too different there, however, CompEx stresses the European certification scheme ‘ATEX’ and European conformity standard ‘CE’, where the IECEx scheme takes a more uniform, international stance.
We should remember that IEC 60079 and EN 60079 are identical, except for some additional annexes. The body of the standards are the same.
The main differences are in the way the course modules are laid out. I am sure many people have been frustrated that they failed one section of their CompEx and had to re-sit that section and gain a pass before their CompEx competency was validated and the certificate issued.
This can be a particular problem with Inspectors, who are not involved in the installation, and installation technicians, who are experts at glanding and terminating, but the wheels fall off when they are tasked to do an inspection, as part of their competency test.
CompEx has Ex01, 02, 03, and 04, which are Electrical Installation, then Inspection, and Instrument Installation and Inspection, but IECEx has EX001, 003, 004, 006, 007, 008 (actually there is a 002, 005, 009 and 010, but let’s deal with the basics first).
Whoa, too many numbers! The IECEx scheme allows you to pick and choose what you need to be certified to, and should you take the full 1,3,4,6,7,8, and fail a module, you can either re-sit the module you failed, or choose to be certified to the other modules you passed, and leave it at that.
EX001 is defined as “competence to apply the basic principles of protection requirements for an electrical worker/engineer/technician” and is a pre-requisite for all the other modules in the scheme.
The training section can be carried out online, but I would recommend face-to-face. It takes me 2 and a half days to impart the knowledge required for Ex001. A few of the differences from CompEx are that IECEx EX001 covers flammable/explosive dust installations, which is additional in CompEx and covered under the Ex05-06 course.
It also goes more in-depth into maintenance and the IECEx repair facilities scheme covered under 60079-19. The competency test for this module comprises two exam papers. One multiple choice question (MCQ) exam (taken online), and a short written answers exam, taken on paper at the current time of writing. The pass mark is 75% for those who like to know the metrics. Oh, and IECEx allows for open-book exams!
That covers Monday through Wednesday, and the competency testing begins afresh with your assessor on Thursday morning, where you will have some time for glanding practice, and then follow on with an Electrical and Instrument installation practical assessment which we will cover in my next blog post. Make sure to subscribe to EUTEX blog so you get notified when a new blog has been published.
Another final little reminder here. Neither CompEx nor IECEx is a training course. They have some instruction, but they are a competency validation scheme for Electrical Crafts persons, Technicians, or Engineers, who already hold valid Industrial Electrical qualifications and are experienced in a relevant industry (for IECEx they require at least 3 years).
Below is a table for a side-to-side comparison of both.
IECEx CoPC | CompEx 01-04 |
Certification of Personnel Competence Part of the IECEx Scheme recognized globally for personnel who work in an explosive atmosphere | CompEx is an international scheme for competency validation and certification of personnel who work in explosive atmospheres |
Open-book exams, standards, and course notes permitted | Closed book exam |
Delivered by individually accredited IECEx Certification Bodies and assessment centers | Delivered by a network of independent training and assessment centers the CompEx scheme supports practitioners in a range of industrial sectors |
Does not stipulate training but requires at least 3 years of industry experience before the assessment | Assessment only can be selected although training immediately before assessment is normal practice |
Encompasses all gas and dust protection techniques | Training covers all gas & dust protection techniques |
Broken into units depending on personnel requirements (electrical worker or engineer) Ex 001: Apply basic principles of protection in explosive atmospheres |
Theory assessment Covers Gas and dust atmospheres – Practical assessment covers IEC60079 Requirements for: EX01: Installation & testing (d, e, n) EX02: Inspection & maintenance (d, e, n) EX03: Installation & testing (i) EX04: Inspection & maintenance (i) |
Individual theory assessment for each unit multiple choice and short answer can be completed concurrently for multiple units. Practical assessments for 003, 004, 005, 006, 007,008. Can be completed concurrently |
EX 01-04 Multiple choice theory assessment |
5 years expiry | 5 years expiry |
Outcome – IECEx Certificate of Personnel Competence (visible on IECEx website) includes photo of individual and wallet card. | Outcome – CompEx Certificate of Core Competence (validity can be checked on CompEx website). |
ADVANTAGES 1. Ability to do single modules – for example Installer 003 2. Ability to view certificates online |
DISADVANTAGES 1- Inability to do single modules – for example Installer needs to do Installation & Inspection 2. Inability to view certificate online |
Broken into units depending on personnel requirements (electrical worker or engineer)
Ex 001: Apply basic principles of protection in explosive atmospheres
Ex 002: Perform classification of hazardous areas
Ex 003: Install explosion-protected equipment and wiring systems
Ex 004: Maintain equipment in explosive atmospheres
Ex 005: Overhaul and repair of explosion-protected equipment
Ex 006: Test electrical installations in or associated with explosive atmospheres
Ex 007: Perform visual and close inspection of electrical installations in or associated with explosive atmospheres
Ex 008: Perform detailed inspection of electrical installations in or associated with explosive atmospheres
Ex 009: Design electrical installations in or associated with explosive atmospheres
Ex 010: Perform audit inspection of electrical installations in or associated with explosive atmospheres
EX01: Installation & testing (d, e, n)
EX02: Inspection & maintenance (d, e, n) EX03: Installation & testing (i)
EX04: Inspection & maintenance (i)
Practical assessments for 003, 004, 005, 006, 007,008. Can be completed concurrently: EX 01-04 Multiple choice theory assessment
ADVANTAGES
1. Ability to do single modules – for example Installer 003
2. Ability to view certificates online:DISADVANTAGES
1- Inability to do single modules – for example Installer needs to do Installation & Inspection
2. Inability to view certificate online
EUTEX offers both IECEx and CompEx training. Click here to view our training catalog and refer to this link for upcoming training dates at our different training centers.
Do you have any training questions?